(L to R) Sen's Gramm and McCain on the campaign trail recently.
Who's to blame for the biggest financial catastrophe of our time? There
are plenty of culprits, but one candidate for lead perp is former Sen.
Phil Gramm.
Eight years ago, as part of a
decades-long anti-regulatory crusade, Gramm pulled a sly legislative
maneuver that greased the way to the multibillion-dollar subprime
meltdown. Yet has Gramm been banished from the corridors of power?
Reviled as the villain who bankrupted Middle America? Hardly. Now a
well-paid executive at a Swiss bank, Gramm cochairs Sen. John McCain's
presidential campaign and advises the Republican candidate on economic
matters. He's been mentioned as a possible Treasury secretary should
McCain win. That's right: A guy who helped screw up the global
financial system could end up in charge of US economic policy. Talk
about a market failure.
Media accounts have identified Gramm as a contender for the top slot at
the Treasury Department if McCain reaches the White House. "If McCain
gets in," frets Lynn Turner, a former chief
sec
accountant, "we'll have more of the same deregulatory mess. I like John
McCain, but given what I know about Phil Gramm, I wouldn't vote for
McCain.
Gramm's long been a
handmaiden to Big Finance. In the 1990s, as chairman of the Senate
banking committee, he routinely turned down Securities and Exchange
Commission chairman Arthur Levitt's requests for more money to police
Wall Street; during this period, the sec's workload shot up 80 percent, but its staff grew only 20 percent. Gramm also opposed an sec
rule that would have prohibited accounting firms from getting too close
to the companies they audited—at one point, according to Levitt's
memoir, he warned the sec chairman that if the commission adopted the
rule, its funding would be cut. And in 1999, Gramm pushed through a
historic banking deregulation bill that decimated Depression-era
firewalls between commercial banks, investment banks, insurance
companies, and securities firms—setting off a wave of merger mania.
But Gramm's most cunning coup
on behalf of his friends in the financial services industry—friends who
gave him millions over his 24-year congressional career—came on
December 15, 2000. It was an especially tense time in Washington. Only
two days earlier, the Supreme Court had issued its decision on Bush v. Gore.
President Bill Clinton and the Republican-controlled Congress were
locked in a budget showdown. It was the perfect moment for a wily
senator to game the system. As Congress and the White House were
hurriedly hammering out a $384-billion omnibus spending bill, Gramm
slipped in a 262-page measure called the Commodity Futures
Modernization Act. Written with the help of financial industry
lobbyists and cosponsored by Senator Richard Lugar (R-Ind.), the
chairman of the agriculture committee, the measure had been considered
dead—even by Gramm. Few lawmakers had either the opportunity or
inclination to read the version of the bill Gramm inserted. "Nobody in
either chamber had any knowledge of what was going on or what was in
it," says a congressional aide familiar with the bill's history.
It's not exactly like Gramm
hid his handiwork—far from it. The balding and bespectacled Texan
strode onto the Senate floor to hail the act's inclusion into the
must-pass budget package. But only an expert, or a lobbyist, could have
followed what Gramm was saying. The act, he declared, would ensure that
neither the sec nor the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (cftc)
got into the business of regulating newfangled financial products
called swaps—and would thus "protect financial institutions from
overregulation" and "position our financial services industries to be
world leaders into the new century."