BOOK REVIEW: Start-Up Nation - The Story of Israel’s Economic Miracle. By Dan Senor and Saul Singer (Jim Miles)
July 23, 2010 (Palestine Chronicle) -- Start-Up Nation - The Story of Israel’s Economic Miracle. Dan Senor and Saul Singer. Council of Foreign Relations Book, McClelland & Stewart. 2009.
There are no Palestinians….
Israel is an amazing place as one puts together the implications from Start-Up Nation. It is a fount of free enterprise can-do entrepreneurial spirit. There are no resistances, although something called an Intifada concerned the authors somewhat, without being specified as to what it is/was. There are no freedom fighters nor insurgents, no guerrillas nor rebellions. For that matter there are no Palestinians as the word has been expunged from the authors’ vocabulary completely (unless it was in a boring anecdotal section that I skim read and missed -- not likely). Israel, except for a few wandering Arabs, was “largely a barren wasteland.”
The only people -- other than Jews, Zionists, and various other national entrepreneurs -- in this book are the terrorists, obviously dealt with very effectively by somebody within the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF). The authors use the media presumption that anyone against the state of Israel must be a terrorist and they are there for seemingly no reason at all, other than that "they are against us and hate us for what we are,"an attitude one could expect from writers with Council on Foreign Relations background. Without these contextual placements, this work fails completely. Even accepting these contextual failures, the "miracle" that is Israel is not very miraculous at all, but is based on what are normal means of establishing national wealth.
Questions
I knew before I read the book that I expected certain elements to be addressed in order for it to be a complete contextual presentation on this supposed miracle. The questions I asked, and that I wrote on the front fly-leaf of the book before reading even the cover flap were:
Does the book discuss the U.S. foreign aid of about $3 billion dollars annually and an etimated 114 billion dollars since inception?
Does it mention the historical period before the war, before the UN Resolution, and immediately following the declaration of the state of Israel, when financial support from the U.K. and the United States had already become common place?
Is there a discussion of the occupation and settlements of prime agricultural land and the control of natural resources (the most important being water)?
Is there any effect of the hostage population of Palestinians in creating cheap labour markets and a captive sales market?
Is the technology trade with the United States discussed, and in its entirety of state-of-the-art military technology and not just the run-of-the-mill, out-of-date stuff sold to other countries? ….and answers. Well no, there are no answers to these questions, except for the one on U.S. technology imports, answered only partially and perhaps inadvertently in a single line in the concluding section of the work. Shimon Peres is cited as saying, “Every technology that arrives in Israel from America, it comes to the army and in five minutes, they change it.” The technology Israel receives is state-of-the-art technology in military and security hardware and software. Biases and Mythologies The biases and purposeful (?) ignorances begin early in the work. The worst representation of this is the authors’ statistic that “defense, counterterrorism, and homeland security companies today represent less than 5 percent of Israel’s gross domestic product.” The implication is that the military has a very small role in the Israeli economy. A closer look at economic statistics reveals a different picture. First of all, defence is given as 6.8 percent of gross domestic product (GDP), a statistic often used to obfuscate the realities of wealth disparities and to hide the distribution of wealth. In 2008, the budget’s 16.2 billion dollars on defence was the highest ratio to GDP of all developed countries, on a per capita basis of $2,300. Aside from the GDP this budgetary figure becomes 17.5 percent of the 2009 $92.6 billion Israeli budget. This sum covers only the defence allocations and does not include the enormous amounts of research and development money that is poured into the technology sector -- being much of the military sector -- by both government and "private" enterprise. That is the main myth presented in this work, that the Israeli economy is a miracle of entrepreneurial free enterprise combined with the can-do chutzpah of a “small and threatened” country. Only normal The general trend of the work indicates two norms. The first is from the 1970s and early 1980s when a series of books were published discussing the highly innovative companies that had made the United States the business/economic leader of the world (In Search of Excellence, Peters and Waterman, Harper Collins. 1982 was the main one). All the business ideals extolled by Senor and Singer have been found in new upstart successful and excellent big businesses all along -- it is not simply an Israeli trait. The other norm that is exposed is the lie of "free enterprise" and "private entrepreneurial" spirit. It does not exist in Israel anymore than it exists in the United States. Instead intensive state supports allowed the industries to be successful -- this is what also initially propelled South Korea, Singapore, and Taiwan to economic power. It is not living “under threat” that made these countries wealthy, nor was it any particular unique strand of spirit, but rather the largesse provided by the state to grow and protect its own industries. Only after the wealth of the country was established did they dare open their markets in a supposedly free enterprise manner, a manner that really leaves the supranational corporations and financiers of the world free to ignore national regulations on a number of fronts Leaving what - chutzpah?
Leaving perhaps that the miracle of Israeli business technological success is built on state support, imported state-of-the-art technology, and a denial that the country is built on the farms, fields and villages of an occupied indigenous people. The way Start-Up Nation explains it all, chutzpah is the distinguishing factor -- perhaps it is also really the force behind the Israel defiance of international law and international humanitarian rights concerning warfare and occupation that the authors choose simply to ignore. An "in your face we don’t give a damn" attitude would certainly explain the erratic controls used by the IDF to enforce the subjugation of the occupied Palestinians. It would also explain the power the Jewish lobby and AIPAC have over the elected representatives of Congress in the United States.
So this book does explain a lot -- by omission in part, by inadvertent admission in others. There is no economic miracle in Israel. There is a state-supported economy that derives much of its initial wealth from stolen land and U.S. largesse economically and militarily.Jim Miles is a Canadian educator and a regular contributor/columnist of opinion pieces and book reviews for The Palestine Chronicle. Miles' work is also presented globally through other alternative websites and news publications.
- CreatedFriday, July 23, 2010
- Last modifiedWednesday, November 06, 2013
SUBSCRIBE
World Desk Activities
phys.org/news/2024-05-composition-gut-microbiota-d…
Composition of gut microbiota could influence decision-making
The way we make decisions in a social context can be explained by psychological, social, and political factors. But what if other forces were at…
phys.org/news/2024-05-whales.html
Are we really about to talk to whales?
The past decade has seen an explosion of new research into some of the most fascinating sounds in the sea: the vocalizations of whales and…
phys.org/news/2024-05-black-teachers-lost-civil-ri…
How Black teachers lost when civil rights won in Brown v. Board
Brown v. Board of Education, the Supreme Court decision that desegregated public schools, stands in the collective national memory as a turning point in America's…
phys.org/news/2024-05-cancer-drug-pollution-global…
Cancer drug pollution is a growing global concern
As incidence of cancer increases globally, the use of cancer drugs is also growing at a rate of approximately 10 percent per year in developed…
phys.org/news/2024-05-summer-northern-hemisphere-h…
Summer 2023 was northern hemisphere's hottest for 2,000 years, tree rings show
The summer of 2023 was the warmest in the non-tropical areas of the northern hemisphere for 2,000 years, a new study has shown.
phys.org/news/2024-05-blooded-dinosaurs-roamed-ear…
When the first warm-blooded dinosaurs roamed Earth
Scientists once thought of dinosaurs as sluggish, cold-blooded creatures. Then research suggested that some could control their body temperature, but when and how that shift…
phys.org/news/2024-05-pyramids-built-lost-river-sc…
Pyramids built along long-lost river, scientists discover
Scientists have discovered a long-buried branch of the Nile river that once flowed alongside more than 30 pyramids in Egypt, potentially solving the mystery of…
phys.org/news/2024-05-danger-beauty-solar-storms.h…
'Danger behind the beauty': More solar storms could be heading our way
Tourists normally have to pay big money and brave cold climates for a chance to see an aurora, but last weekend many people around the…
techxplore.com/news/2024-05-terminal-diode-wireles…
A promising three-terminal diode for wireless communication and optically driven computing
Two-terminal devices are electronic components connected to electrical circuits via two electrical terminals. Although these components are the key building blocks of most existing devices,…
medicalxpress.com/news/2024-05-covid-vaccinations-…
Repeat COVID-19 vaccinations elicit antibodies that neutralize variants, other viruses
The COVID-19 pandemic is over, but the virus that caused it is still here, sending thousands of people to the hospital each week and spinning…
Latest Stories
Electronic Frontier Foundation
- The Alaska Supreme Court Takes Aerial Surveillance’s Threat to Privacy Seriously, Other Courts Should Too May 29, 2024
- Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Section 230 | EFFector 36.7 May 29, 2024
- A Wider View on TunnelVision and VPN Advice May 29, 2024
- EFF Submission to the Oversight Board on Posts That Include “From the River to the Sea” May 28, 2024
The Intercept
- Not Just Coastal Elites: Here’s How Three Rust Belt Colleges Protested Israel’s War in Gaza June 02, 2024
- Guantánamo Prosecutors Accused of “Outrageous” Misconduct for Trying to Use Torture Testimony June 01, 2024
- He Made a PowerPoint on Mothers Starving in Gaza. Then He Lost His Government Job. May 31, 2024
- Columbia Coincidentally Rewrites Disciplinary Rules Just in Time to Screw Over Student Protesters May 31, 2024
VTDigger
- Bennington County Senator Dick Sears has died at 81 June 02, 2024
- Moving and shaking at Montpelier’s Latin dance nights June 02, 2024
- Young Writers Project: ‘Papa Simmons’ June 02, 2024
- Leaving Big Pharma for mushroom farming, Wiseman family finds purpose in Worcester June 02, 2024